No. 157 - 17 November 2026
Who bears the costs of a conditional counterclaim for revocation if the infringement action is dismissed and the counterclaim consequently remains undecided?
Three UPC Local Divisions have now provided three different answers: the defendant must bear the costs, the claimant must bear them, or each party must bear its own costs.
The Court of Appeal has confirmed that counterclaims for revocation may be made conditional upon a finding of infringement. However, it has not yet resolved the resulting question of costs.
1. Local Division Munich: The defendant bears the costs
In Emboline v AorticLab, the defendant initially filed an unconditional counterclaim for revocation but made it conditional upon a finding of infringement during the oral hearing.
The Munich Local Division dismissed the infringement action and consequently did not decide on the counterclaim.
Nevertheless, it ordered the defendant to bear the costs of the counterclaim (paras. 69–73).
The Court acknowledged that defendants must file a counterclaim if they wish to challenge validity in infringement proceedings. However, it considered that the defendant had voluntarily decided to make the counterclaim conditional, thereby preventing a decision on its merits.
According to Munich, the costs of the undecided counterclaim were therefore unnecessary costs within the meaning of Art. 69(3) UPCA, which the defendant had caused and consequently had to bear.
Since the claimant was unsuccessful in the infringement action, while the defendant was responsible for the costs of the counterclaim, the Court ultimately ordered each party to bear its own overall costs.
Further details on the Munich decision can be found in our earlier blog post, UPC Insights No. 113 of 20 January 2026: https://www.meissnerbolte.com/en/upc/upc-blog/no-113-munich-local-division-rejects-infringement-claim-for-embolic-protection-device/
2. Local Division Mannheim: The claimant bears the costs
The Mannheim Local Division reached the opposite conclusion in SK nexilis v Volta Energy Solutions.
Here, too, the defendant made its counterclaim conditional during the oral hearing, before the Court had expressed its preliminary view on infringement. The infringement action was dismissed, leaving the counterclaim undecided.
Mannheim held that the claimant must bear the costs of both proceedings (paras. 128–139).
The Court emphasised that defendants cannot simply invoke invalidity as a defence without filing a counterclaim for revocation. Moreover, the parties must fully substantiate their positions on validity during the written procedure, irrespective of whether the counterclaim will ultimately require a decision.
The resulting costs cannot therefore be considered unnecessary merely because the counterclaim remains undecided. Mannheim expressly disagreed with the Munich Local Division on this point.
Instead, Mannheim considered the claimant to be the unsuccessful party within the meaning of Art. 69(1) UPCA. The defendant had prevailed with its primary defence of non-infringement, while the counterclaim had been necessary only as a secondary defence.
The Court also referred to an earlier decision of the Paris Local Division of 19 August 2026 (Orange v HMD Global, UPC_CFI_301/2025, para. 99), which likewise allocated the costs of the proceedings to the unsuccessful infringement claimant, although without specifically addressing the allocation of costs attributable to the conditional counterclaim.
3. Local Division Hamburg: Each party bears its own costs
Most recently, the Hamburg Local Division adopted a third approach in Steros GPA Innovative v OTEC Präzisionsfinish.
Unlike in Munich and Mannheim, the defendant had made its counterclaim conditional from the outset. Again, the infringement action was dismissed, and the counterclaim remained undecided.
Hamburg expressly discussed the conflicting approaches taken by Munich, Mannheim and Paris before concluding that each party should bear its own costs relating to the counterclaim (paras. 61–63).
The Court acknowledged that the defendant had been compelled to file the counterclaim as a secondary line of defence against the infringement action.
However, it also considered that the claimant had no influence over whether the conditional counterclaim would ultimately be decided.
According to Hamburg, where the condition is not fulfilled and no decision is made on the counterclaim, neither party can be regarded as successful or unsuccessful in those proceedings. Consequently, each party must bear its own costs under Art. 69(1) UPCA.
Hamburg expressly stated that this approach applies at least where the counterclaim is conditional from the outset.